Let your spirit glow

with with a fresh new year

Jewelry

Who do you love

About the Founders


In 2012, Machelle Wagner, a dedicated resident of Chesterton, Indiana, founded Chelle's, fueled by her vision to create a unique and captivating shopping experience. She purchased the iconic Barb's Bakery building at 211 Broadway determined to craft a space that would uplift and inspire her community. With the invaluable help of her parents, Sharon and Fred Millet, and her husband, Joe Wagner, the shop's revitalization began. Chesterton, situated at the southernmost tip of Lake Michigan, boasts stunning natural beauty, with sand dunes and forests, as well as state and national parks. Machelle's commitment to preserving this beauty led her to partner with manufacturers who share her dedication to environmental responsibility.

Two years later, Fred and Sharon, Machelle's parents, seized an exciting opportunity by acquiring the building next door at 209 Broadway. Green Garage emerged and a perfect partnership formed. This second shop showcases a unique array of gifts, beautifully renovated furniture, gently worn Second Love items, and artisan workshops. Years later, a doorway between the shops was created, and the name was changed to Chelle's Boutique & Garage, where a vibrant team of creative and friendly individuals came together. Now, people enthusiastically describe the shop as a treasured local gem. We extend a warm welcome for you to visit, for we believe that every person who enters our shop is a friend we have yet to meet.

Why Clients Love Us

Operated by the sweetest shop owner around, Chelle's is a joyful place to browse and shop for just about anyone you might need a gift for or to splurge on yourself for some new clothes!! Hoping to score something unique and fantastic? Head to the Second Love rack!
Linda S.
Linda S.
Operated by the sweetest shop owner around, Chelle's is a joyful place to browse and shop for just about anyone you might need a gift for or to splurge on yourself for some new clothes!! Hoping to score something unique and fantastic? Head to the Second Love rack!
The best thing about this shop is the staff. No matter if you are just browsing or truly shopping the employees make you feel like family! I love that the most!!
Joyce L.
Joyce L.
The best thing about this shop is the staff. No matter if you are just browsing or truly shopping the employees make you feel like family! I love that the most!!
Quaint and welcoming. There is something for everyone.
Loretta B.
Loretta B.
Quaint and welcoming. There is something for everyone.
A quaint shop packed with cute and unique surprises filled with charm.
Amy W.
Amy W.
A quaint shop packed with cute and unique surprises filled with charm.
Just a gem! Love the atmosphere! The Gals that work there are always so nice! Eclectic, and I love the clothes! I love the bags! Love the shoes! Love the Second Love items, and I always find cool items for gifts! Hard to find this nice of a store in any small town!
Sonya M.
Sonya M.
Just a gem! Love the atmosphere! The Gals that work there are always so nice! Eclectic, and I love the clothes! I love the bags! Love the shoes! Love the Second Love items, and I always find cool items for gifts! Hard to find this nice of a store in any small town!
Lovely place, lovely people, lovely clothes, lovely selection of gifts! Did I mention Chelle's is LOVELY ... Never walked out without a lovely purchase!
Renee H.
Renee H.
Lovely place, lovely people, lovely clothes, lovely selection of gifts! Did I mention Chelle's is LOVELY ... Never walked out without a lovely purchase!

Visit Us

We are always happy to meet a new friend

Our address
211 Broadway, Chesterton, Indiana 46304
Get directions

Open hours (winter hours)

Tuesday - Friday 10-5 Saturday 10-4